Key takeaways
-
Differentiated instruction and enrichment opportunities remove barriers and challenge students ready for deeper learning, all without lowering expectations.
-
Clear learning targets and frequent checkpoints allow teachers to identify student needs and catch misunderstandings early.
-
Utilizing flexible grouping and tailored language supports directly improves student access to learning.
The question of how to differentiate instruction is one every teacher ponders from time to time. We understand that offering students multiple paths to mastery of a standard is effective instruction. What’s often less clear is exactly how to differentiate instruction in a way that truly creates those routes.
Understanding what good differentiation does and doesn’t do is the first step. Differentiation is not offering fifteen exclusive lessons to 20 students. That’s an untenable and unrealistic view of what’s truly possible in a classroom. In reality, differentiated instruction provides students with multiple ways to engage with the same concepts at varying levels. It means planning instruction in a way that intentionally builds opportunities to overcome learning obstacles, language barriers, and other challenges that might stand in the way of student mastery. It creates opportunities for enrichment while also making learning more accessible for struggling learners.
The average classroom today serves a variety of students who may have looked very different just a generation ago. Our classrooms are filled with students from different backgrounds, language experiences, skill levels, and learning needs. This creates incredible opportunities for growth and collaboration in the classroom, but it also requires educators to think carefully about how to differentiate instruction.
Teachers also have access to more digital supports than ever before, including tools available through a K-12 teaching and learning platform.
What is differentiated instruction?
At its core, differentiated instruction means using what we already know about effective teaching practices to intentionally provide students with the support they need to access learning. It’s recognizing that barriers to learning are not always tied to a student’s ability or understanding of a concept.
Sometimes a student understands a concept long before they can comfortably explain it out loud or in writing. Other students may know exactly what to do but struggle to focus during certain parts of instruction due to distractions, noise, or the classroom pace. Differentiation asks teachers to carefully examine those situations before assuming a student simply doesn’t understand the material.
Because differentiated instruction does address so many unique needs, it can feel chaotic and overwhelming in theory. In practice, however, it often brings order to confusion. As with so many things in education, differentiation starts with classroom management. Simply understanding what a teacher expects and how students should move through the day can provide foundational support that helps reduce anxiety, sensory overload, and other learning barriers. From there, teachers are better able to focus on specific instructional strategies.
A good place to start when differentiating a lesson or unit is to consider three questions:
- Where will students struggle during this lesson?
- What can I do to prevent that struggle?
- How can I provide enrichment for students ready for a more challenging approach?
Why is differentiated instruction important?
We all know that every student learns differently. We know it so well that it’s become an educational cliché. However, the conversation often stops before we ask, “What are the consequences of not planning for this reality in our everyday practice?”
When we strive to provide instruction that students can meaningfully access, we create a layer of stability that can’t exist without intentionality. Frustration is a natural byproduct of instruction that constantly leaves students feeling incapable or defeated. Over time, that loss of confidence becomes part of how students define themselves as learners. Before long, students may develop gaps in their learning, a negative view of their abilities, and growing distrust in what school can offer them.
On the other hand, that same student in a classroom with language supports such as sentence frames and vocabulary scaffolds can use those tools to work past some of that frustration. Through strategic partnering, they’re able to participate more comfortably in discussions and spend less energy keeping up with the language demands of the lesson. That shift allows them to focus more directly on the learning.
How to differentiate instruction
After setting and explicitly teaching procedures and expectations in the general classroom, it’s time to start thinking about how to most effectively differentiate specific concepts, standards, and lessons. A good place to start is by identifying exactly what students should know or be able to do by the end of the lesson. Having a clear understanding of what students should be able to do after mastering a concept provides a blueprint for instruction. Well-intentioned differentiation falls apart if the teacher doesn’t fully internalize what they are teaching and assessing.
For instance, a lesson designed for sixth graders to solve real-world problems using ratios and unit rates is not about English proficiency or reading stamina. It’s measuring a student’s ability to understand ratios and unit rates while applying proportional reasoning. A simple, clear, student-friendly learning target might be, “I can use ratios and unit rates to solve real-world math problems.”
However, learning targets themselves don’t create full differentiation. They show students the end goal, but building success criteria around that learning target shows students the steps needed to get there. Good success criteria for this target isolate mathematical thinking. Those guideposts help both the student and the teacher understand the actual learning taking place and avoid false negatives.
Success criteria for this target might look something like this:
- I can identify the ratio in the problem.
- I can calculate a unit rate.
- I can explain how I solved the problem.
- I can compare two ratios to answer a problem.
After intentionally determining the learning path to mastering the standard, it’s time to consider the hurdles that might prevent students from reaching that goal. Some potential false negatives in a standard like this might include language barriers, vocabulary gaps, and reading fluency challenges. A dense word problem full of content-specific vocabulary and complex syntax could create multiple issues for students that have nothing to do with their mathematical understanding.
Knowing this, teachers can plan a variety of tools to help remove those barriers. Providing vocabulary cards or posters can help students clarify words like ratio, unit rate, equivalent, and even words that might unexpectedly become obstacles, such as “compare.” Reading the problem aloud initially, highlighting key information, and incorporating visuals can help students overcome reading challenges that might otherwise prevent them from accessing the problem. Students who quickly master the skill can extend their thinking by writing their own real-world problem examples, explaining their reasoning to a partner, or comparing multiple solution methods.
5 Effective Differentiation Strategies
Practically, these supports can be used not just by those with a direct need, but by all students in the classroom.
1. Clarify Learning Expectations
One of the most effective differentiated instruction strategies is to set clear, explicit learning expectations. Learning targets and success criteria that are student-friendly, posted publicly, and referenced often help teachers better identify potential pitfalls students might face.
For example, a student may turn in an essay that appears to show a misunderstanding of a science concept when the real issue is difficulty with writing conventions rather than scientific understanding. A teacher who has clearly identified the intended learning outcome is better able to recognize that distinction and offer students alternative ways to demonstrate learning, such as verbal reports, guided writing supports, or visual representations.
2. Flexible Grouping
Flexible grouping is not just about heterogeneous groupings. That’s too neat a package for the impact flexible grouping can have when used strategically. Groups of students at varying levels can be a powerful way to build classroom community while supporting academic growth. However, many other configurations are possible.
Pairing a student who is strong in computation with a student who excels at mathematical reasoning can create a different kind of learning experience. Grouping bilingual students together during collaborative learning experiences outside of designated English language instruction can help reduce language barriers that may otherwise limit participation. Flexible grouping is most effective when used intentionally and adjusted in response to what the teacher observes during instruction.
3. Language Supports
Language supports carry high value, often at a proportionally small cost. Word walls and vocabulary activities undoubtedly help English language learners, but they are also available for any student who needs clarification. Translating specific vocabulary words into common native languages represented in the classroom can make word walls even more impactful. Teachers looking for additional ideas to support multilingual learners can also explore strategies for English language learners in math.
Sentence starters and stems can help students push past the feeling of “I don’t know where to start!” while also providing stronger support for students with learning gaps. Highlighting and reviewing key terms in readings is a quick and powerful language support that can help multiple student populations better access instruction.
4. Checkpoints
Building in checkpoints helps keep learning moving forward. Good checkpoints offer formative assessments and opportunities to capitalize on teachable moments. Some powerful options are:
- Exit tickets
- Turn-and-talk discussions
- Quick written reflections
- Thumbs up/down or whiteboard checks
- Digital polls or short interactive quizzes
Checkpoints work best when they are intentional and planned, but they can also be used during natural moments that arise during lessons.
5. Enrichment
One aspect of differentiated instruction that often gets lost in the demands of teaching is enrichment. Advanced students are too often left to their own curiosity and motivation to push learning beyond the standard lesson. The upside is that once a teacher approaches planning with a differentiation lens, the problem of enrichment becomes easier to solve.
Building in deeper-thinking questions for everyone, or as an extension, can provide more ways to interact with content. Creating original examples, occasionally serving as peer mentors, and inquiry-based follow-ups can all be planned in advance and provide a challenge for any student ready to dig a little deeper.
Closing Thoughts
Differentiated instruction is not about perfection. It’s about good planning that takes into account not only the needs of individual students, but also the potential problems that might arise during learning. Teaching with a differentiated lens is not about unrealistic demands that require more time and energy than any teacher could reasonably be expected to have. It’s about intention, high-impact strategies, and having a plan before instruction even begins. Small intentional changes are at the heart of differentiated instruction.
